Learning in vivo

Pondering about shadowing on an examination bed

Shadowing entails following someone else while they are at work to learn about that person's job. Often shadowing takes place during orientation (onboarding) at a new place of work, or new job by initially shadowing a more experienced employee.

While undergoing an abdominal ultrasound examination, I pondered shadowing. The sonographer gave several instructions while operating the ultrasonic imaging device to produce diagnostic images. While lying on my back or either side with my hands above my head, I have been asked to breathe in deeply and holding my breath during scanning. I was also asked to pinch my nose, puff my cheeks, and hold my breath during scanning; and to engage in starting sit-ups, and to hold my abdominal muscles tight while scanning. These are the various techniques to acquire the best possible three-dimensional diagnostic images for the ultrasound report. If a student-sonographer that is undergoing clinical training, were to only receive the images, there would not be much learning opportunity. However, if the individual were introduced to me, my consent requested, actions explained while observing—being told what is done and why, then significant training would probably be derived from such shadowing.

Time spent shadowing intellectual work seems to require telepathy. Often shadowing is advocated as a means for existing employees who are aspiring to advancement, to gain experience laterally. However, unless the future role-taker is entrusted aspects of work to intellectually engage with on their own, while under supervision and guidance, little learning could be expected. Merely being kept in the loop through email traffic does not allow for shadowing of the intellectual processes involved.

Virtual experiential learning is feasible

If swimming schools can further mastery through virtual swimming school, instead of letting learners slide back; and if township children can continue with violin lessons amid lockdown using WhatsApp; then surely higher and further education can achieve work-integrated learning virtually.

The COVID-19 pandemic may have grounded flights and put the world into lockdown, and the legendary African safari might be on hold; but inventive conservationists introduced virtual safaris in living rooms through cameras mounted to vehicles. Paid-for private tours by means of Zoom video calls will soon start. A zoo introduced drive-through animal viewing affording families the opportunity to ‘visit’ a zoo while in isolation.

Lockdown abruptly halted traditional workplace-based experiential learning. Solutions are explored for especially students that would have graduated at the end of 2020. As the economy is gradually reignited traditional workplace-based experiential learning might still be hampered. Institutions are recommended to virtually engage the relevant communities of practice and professional or vocational bodies, in order to seek opportunities to virtually ‘exhibit’ relevant graduate attributes, problems experienced and critical cross-field outcomes [CCFOs] that need to be attained. Filming need not be professionally done. Students can virtually engage with the virtual exemplars and through structured online learning gain their prerequisite ‘experience’.

If numerous virtual concerts work, if drive-though strip shows are supported, why would virtual experiential learning not be feasible?

What can electronic experiential learning appropriate from the COVID-19 pandemic?

When governments locked down countries, initiatives blossomed. Athletes, for example, started running virtual marathons in their gardens. On Easter Sunday evening Andrea Bocelli made history by presenting the 'Music for Hope' concert from an empty Milan cathedral, peaking at 2.8 million concurrent viewers. The biggest ever classical live stream in YouTube’s history. There were more than 28 million viewings from across the globe took place in the first 24 hours thereafter.

MyBroadband reported a significant increase in South Africa’s Internet usage since the start of the COVID-19 lockdown, peaking over 1.1Tbps on the evening of 25 March during President Cyril Ramaphosa’s announcement of the lockdown. Traffic across NAPAfrica’s exchange points reached a record 1.04Tbps the day after. Vodacom, one of South Africa's mobile phone network operators reported a jump of 40-percent since a nationwide lockdown. Afrihost recorded a 44% increase in data usage, compared to usage in January and February, with video streaming the biggest contributor. Vox recorded a 50% increase in fibre-to-the-home traffic. Elsewhere, for example in Kenya, Safaricom noted a 70% jump in data usage during COVID-19 lockdown.

Many believe that experiential learning cannot be done online. Bates (2014) contested this, saying “experiential learning is [indeed] like most design models: it is independent of the mode of delivery. What matters is how well it is done.” He advocates that there is indeed a range of teaching design models enabling the embedding of real world contexts into learning, namely problem-based learning, case-based learning, project-based learning, inquiry-based learning, cooperative (work- or community-based) education, and apprenticeships. Beard, Wilson and McCarter (2007) coined the expression E²-learning with regard to the fusion between experiential-electronic learning (EE-Learning) and e-learning.

While bored and livestreaming, at 01h00, Justin LaBoy, a former professional basketball player and a social media personality, got the idea to recreate a virtual club atmosphere on Instagram for his more than 60,000 followers. He and Justin Dior Combs, an entrepreneur, started the ‘Respectfully Justin Show’. As result of lockdown, bars and strip clubs may not operate, and around much of the world many were forced to close nearly overnight. Thousands of bartenders, bottle service girls and dancers have been left with no income. Many organisations resorted to recreating a digital experience to support members. Magic City, a strip club in Atlanta, started offering ‘virtual lap dances’. Tory Lanez, a rapper, began hosting dance nights, called ‘Quarantine Radio’ for his 7.5 million followers. LaBoy says that exotic dancers immediately requested to be guests on his livestream and his followers loved it. He felt he cannot let them dance for free, and pinned a dancer’s Cash App to the top of the feeds, so that followers could send them money. One dancer, Sasha, who has been featured on the pop-up show said “If it wasn’t for Justin … I don’t know what I would have done or how I would have paid my bills or gotten food in my house”.

Most, if not all, production or work processes, operations, and executions could be filmed and streamed. Students need not necessary be physically present to experience what they need exposure to. If a strip dance or lap dance can be done virtually, why not simulated experiential learning? It need not be costly filming.

https://www.classicfm.com/artists/andrea-bocelli/concert-empty-milan-duomo-cathedral-world-record/

https://www.enca.com/business/vodacom-sees-40-jump-data-usage-people-stay-home

https://www.cnbcafrica.com/news/2020/04/14/kenyas-safaricom-sees-70-jump-in-data-usage-during-covid-19-lockdown/

https://mybroadband.co.za/news/fibre/346757-the-76tb-man-south-africas-biggest-bandwidth-hog-during-the-lockdown.html

https://www.nytimes.com/2020/04/10/style/justin-laboy-instagram-strip-clubs-live.html?algo=bandit-story_desk_filter&fellback=false&imp_id=701449925&imp_id=455391584&action=click&module=editorContent&pgtype=Article&region=CompanionColumn&contentCollection=Trending

https://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-8210749/Virtual-strip-clubs-popping-Instagram-dancers-raking-18-000.html

Bates, T. (2014). Can you do experiential learning online? Assessing design models for experiential learning. Electronically accessible from https://www.tonybates.ca/2014/12/01/can-you-do-experiential-learning-online-assessing-design-models-for-experiential-learning/

Beard, C.; Wilson, J.P. & McCarter, R. (2007). Towards a Theory of e-Learning: Experiential e-Learning. Journal of Hospitality, Leisure, Sport and Tourism Education, 6(2), 3-15. https://pdfs.semanticscholar.org/95b4/bf51ed82edf9bb529574d65df250fb595df7.pdf

Online programmes which include work-integrated learning could pose serious pedagogical challenges

An increasing need for the flexibility of fully online study while earning, in order to enhance career trajectories, is prevalent. However, “implementing online learning can pose serious pedagogical challenges particularly when programs contain work-integrated learning (WIL) components”, if not perceived as ‘can’t be done’, say Quinn, Cioffi, Hill, Kor, Longford, Moller and Rathore (2019: 1). Contrary to online learning frequently being perceived as a passive and second class; the practical outcomes are accomplishable.

A wide-dispersion of online students renders it impractical to include a shared physical learning site. Quinn et al. (2019) report, for example, on the creation of an interactive virtual learning environment, in collaboration with construction companies, through significant state funding, portraying the construction of an eight-storey building. This high quality resource is supplemented by “comparatively low-cost environments demonstrating the construction of a residential, industrial, and multi-storey building construction sites”, including “embedded images, explanatory videos and documents which students can interact with” (Quinn et al. 2019). Virtual site visits, “comparable to traditional site visits”, are embedded in online learning materials in order to “motivate students to reflect on and refine their understandings based on the authentic context they are experiencing”.

Quinn et al. (2019) report the benefits construction management, for example, students reap from repeat visits to the same site, namely appreciating “the spatial constraints (e.g. how construction products are related to one another in a particular building site) and temporal constraints (e.g. the dependencies for coordinating subcontractors)” as well as “how these constraints change over the life of the building project”. However, difficulties in aligning the timing of visits to construction sites could result in students developing a piecemeal understanding of the construction worksite. Virtual field trips include, for example, augmented realities; simulations; and learning environments making use of 360-degree images of the construction of a building over time; contribute to a four- dimensional virtual work-integrated learning environment.

Quinn, D.; Cioffi, E.; Hill, S.; Kor, M.; Longford, A.; Moller, R.; & Rathore, P. (2019). Implementing work-integrated learning in online construction management courses. Journal of University Teaching & Learning Practice, 16(1). Available at: https://ro.uow.edu.au/jutlp/vol16/iss1/9

Cornell system for taking notes of real-experience learning

Deriving learning from experiences does not merely happen. A note-taking system devised at the University of Cornell, by an education professor, Walter Pauk, in the 1950s, could remarkably enhance the learning from experiences. A spiral reporter's notepad (or any of choice) works well. Space of 2-3 cm is left at the top to record the date, setting and circumstances. A line is drawn vertically, about a quarter to a third, from the left, leaving about 4-5 cms at the bottom. The column on the right serves as space to take notes of observations, explanations, facts, descriptions, etc. The column on the left use for key words, questions, etc. The space at the bottom is meant for recording a summary after the experience, for example at the end of the day.

Due to the efficiency of this method it is still being advocated; iPad templates exist for easy note taking; as well as pre-formated Cornell notepaper and guides to create a MS Word template; or PDF-format versions to print for use.

The Dr Walter Pauk Cornell system emphasises the five Rs, namely Record, Reduce, Recite, Reflect and Review.

Work-related learning concisely: Learn from experiences; reflect and articulate lessons; and apply in future

A Work Experience Group regards ‘work-related learning’ as a process in which students of all ages can learn, with guidance, from experiences in the world of work; and if upon reflection (and absorption, p. 11) such students can articulate the lessons learned; they should be able to apply the lessons to future opportunities encountered in work and in life. Work-related learning includes during term-time in voluntary and paid employment; sandwich or block-release courses; and other academically recognised learning. (p. 7)

Guidance, mentioned above, is emphasised (p. 19) namely: “Students who are well prepared for their work-based learning are likely to learn more and to make better employees.” It is further argued that greater consistency and clarity with regard to (a) the objectives of the placement; (b) the expectations the student, the employer and the institution—the three key players; (c) the roles and responsibilities of each; and (d) how achievements will be measured. A good practice guide with regard to, among others these, should be implemented.

The Work Experience Group mentioned above had been established in November 2000 by the UK Department for Education and Skills (DfES, formerly the Department for Education and Employment) with the following terms of reference: “To consider options and recommend a strategy for increasing the full range of opportunities for all Higher Education (HE) students to undertake work experience, including paid and voluntary work, in a way that better enhances their employability.” (p. 2, Chairman Richard A Brown’s foreword).

Work Experience Group Report. 2002. Department for Education and Skills. Nottingham: DfES Publications. Electronically accessed 9 November 2013 from http://www.asetonline.org/documents/WRLR.pdf

Many stories and sometimes sharing of chapters

Cooperative Work-integrated Education “should provide opportunity for [workplace] engagement
and [contextual learning] rather than relying on lectures and [workshop or laboratory experiences] from” academia (replaced ‘cross-cultural engagement and education’ with [workplace] engagement and [contextual learning]; and ‘lectures and teaching’ with lectures and [workshop or laboratory experiences], Richmond et al, 2010: 66) in my opinion.

The post-title is borrowed from the late at night words of Teacon Simeonoff, a leader from Old Harbor community—the Alutiiq, or southern coastal people of the Native peoples of Alaska—while sitting with ten other people around a campfire on a nearby island, who said: “We all have a story and sometimes we share the same chapters” (abstract Richmond et al, 2010: 63).

Richmond, L.; Di Piero, D.; Espinoza, F.; Simeonoff, T. & Faraday, M. 2010. We Shared the Same
Chapter: Collaboration, Learning, and Transformation from the 2008 Subsistence, the Environment, and Community Well-Being Native Youth Exchange in Old Harbor, Alaska Project. Journal of Higher Education Outreach and Engagement, Volume 14, Number 4, pp. 63-82.

Sustainability as emerging academic field challenges what is taught and how

If higher education graduates are to cope with society’s sustainability-challenges, universities must provide students with interactive, experiential, transformative, and real-world learning to suitably prepare them; say Brundiers, Wiek and Redman (2010). The authors undertook a synthesis of literature on sustainability education (an emerging academic field) with the view of determining how real-world learning can contribute to building key competencies in sustainability. Consensus exists that the capacity-uilding pathways of sustainability education should engage the “head, hands, and heart”.

Sustainability education is concerned with complex non-linear problems with long-term implications; that cut across economic, social, and environmental domains; not just on local but global scales; and involve high degrees of damage potential; and therefore urgency. These often manifest as a conglomerate of problems that require sophisticated “post-normal” solutions and elaborate problem-solving techniques; that challenges basic assumptions; and call for systems-thinking, anticipation, and participatory strategy-building models across established disciplines.

Key competencies in sustainability cannot be acquired by being told about sustainable development. Students need to see and work within a living learning place. They need to experience what a sustainable lifestyle means. Learning must focus on real-world problems, exposing students to corresponding real-world settings. A variety of learning models might be considered, for example project- and/or problem-based learning; service learning; and internships. However, not all real-world learning opportunities are appropriate. Some are more appropriate for extracurricular activities; whereas others do not relate well to the key features of sustainability. Brundiers, Wiek and Redman (2010: 311) present this “overview of key differences among dominant models of real-world learning formats”:

	Project-based learning	Service learning	Internship
Outcomes: what students learn/benefit	Collaborative problem-solving capacity	Education and teaching capacity	Professional working experience; career development
Practices: what students do	Collaborating with partners to develop solution approach	Educating people	Assisting or working on a professional project
Interaction with stakeholder	Two-way knowledge generation (co-production)	One-way knowledge transfer (students to community)	One-way knowledge transfer (employer to student and student to employer)
Integration of theory and practice	Explicit, supervised by faculty and stakeholder	Implicit, not supervised by faculty	Implicit, not supervised by faculty
Impacts on world	Systemic innovation	Support of social innovation and change	Modular innovation

Brundiers, K.; Wiek, A. & Redman C. L. 2010. Real-world learning opportunities in sustainability: from classroom into the real world. International Journal of Sustainability in Higher Education, 11 (4): 308-324.

The journal (IJSHE) is published by Emerald Group Publishing Limited in conjunction with Society of University Leaders for a Sustainable Future (ULSF).

Does experience-taking offer a means of simulated learning?

Encounters with fictional characters offer the potential exposure “a diverse array of personalities, perspectives, events, outcomes, and realizations” remark Geoff Kaufman and Lisa Libby (2012: 1). Literature allows the imaginary transportation to other places; to other times; into characters with personality traits different from us; or the engagement in actions or the holding of ideas that are being aspired to. Biographies and fictional tales allow for the experiencing of life journeys of other people, which in turn may be an eye opener to the minds, struggles, achievements of individuals form diverse backgrounds. However, what is described here by no means happen automatically. On the contrary, it is required that the reader move beyond being a mere reader or spectator. It requires connecting to characters to such an extent that one step “into their proverbial shoes and experience the story from their perspective” (2012: 2), essentially to image becoming the characters while being in the world of the narrative. Kaufman and Libby (2012: 1) identify this as experience-taking and define the concept as “the imaginative process of spontaneously assuming the identity of a character in a narrative and simulating that character’s thoughts, emotions, behaviors, goals, and traits as if they were one’s own”. They undertook research to explore which factors facilitate and which impede experience-taking. They also demonstrate the influential impact experience-taking may have on the self-concepts, goals and actions of engaged readers. They further differentiate experience-taking from perspective-taking.

Kaufman and Libby (citing Oatley 1999, 2012: 2) suggests that experience-taking occurs when “readers simulate the events of a narrative as though they were a particular character in the story world, adopting the character’s mindset and perspective as the story progresses rather than orienting themselves as an observer or evaluator of the character”. In order to succeed in experience-taking, the reader need to set aside key aspects of own identity—“such as their beliefs, memories, personality traits and ingroup affiliations—and instead assume the identity of a protagonist, accepting the character’s decisions, outcomes, and reactions as their own” (Kaufman & Libby, 2012: 2).

It is suggested, based on the prediction and research findings of Kaufman and Libby (2012), that the better a simulation is capable to evoke experience-taking and to enable the participant to mimic the character’s subjective experience, the better is the potential of adapting self-concept, attitudes, and behaviour.

Kaufman, G. F.; Libby, L. K. 2012. Changing beliefs and behavior through experience-taking. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, Mar 26.

Visit also: 'Losing Yourself' in a Fictional Character Can Affect Your Real Life

Oatley, K. 1999. Meetings of minds: Dialogue, sympathy, and identification, in reading fiction. Poetics, 26, 439–454. doi:10.1016/S0304-422X(99)00011-X